Start With a Published Baseline, Then Get a Local Quote
There is no authoritative Westchester-wide rate sheet for pet sitting. Individual caregivers set prices, and a quote can change with service length, dates, number and type of pets, medication needs, travel, and how much of the day or night the sitter must remain in your home.
The most defensible published benchmark available in 2026 is national platform data, not a claimed local average. Rover's March 2026 guide reports U.S. averages of $21.80 for a dog drop-in visit, $55.45 per night for house sitting in the owner's home, and $49.01 per night for boarding in the sitter's home. Rover says those figures were pulled from its data in September 2025. Its May 2026 cat guide reports $22 per drop-in, $58.33 per night for in-home house sitting, and $44.97 per night for boarding in the sitter's home.
Westchester quotes may be above or below those figures. Use the benchmarks to spot what needs explanation, then compare at least three written local totals for the same dates and care instructions.
Published 2026 Planning Baselines
These are published national Rover averages, not surveyed Westchester prices and not a promise of what a local sitter will charge.
| Service | Published National Baseline | Confirm in the Local Quote |
|---|---|---|
| Dog drop-in visit | $21.80 per visit | Visit length, walk included or separate, number of pets, medication, and holiday rate |
| Dog house sitting in your home | $55.45 per night | Hours present, daytime absences, walks, arrival/departure times, and household tasks |
| Dog boarding in sitter's home | $49.01 per night | Other animals or clients present, supervision, pickup window, and extended-care charge |
| Cat drop-in visit | $22 per visit | Visit length, feeding/litter tasks, number of cats, medication, and update frequency |
| Cat house sitting in your home | $58.33 per night | Hours present, number of visits or overnight window, medication, and household tasks |
| Cat boarding in sitter's home | $44.97 per night | Room setup, other animals, stress plan, pickup window, and extended-care charge |
Why Two 'Overnight' Quotes Can Be Very Different
The word overnight does not define a standard level of care. Put the schedule in writing before comparing totals.
| Quote Item | Why It Changes the Total | Question to Ask |
|---|---|---|
| Presence window | A sleep-only stay is different from near-continuous care | What time will you arrive, leave, and be away during the day? |
| Extended care | A late final-day pickup can add part or all of another nightly rate | What is the included pickup window and the overage rule? |
| Additional pets | Platforms and independent sitters may price each added pet | What is the complete total for every pet on the booking? |
| Medication or special handling | Time, skill, and risk differ by task | Can you safely perform the exact task, and is it included? |
| Holiday dates | The higher rate may apply to more than the holiday itself | Which dates use the holiday rate, and what is the all-in total? |
| Travel and household duties | Mileage, key pickup, plants, mail, or other tasks may be separate | Which non-pet tasks and travel charges are included? |
App Platforms vs Independent Sitters
Rover and Wag let caregivers set their own rates, so neither platform has one universal Westchester price. Rover currently says providers take home 80% of booking earnings. Wag says its app displays an estimated range based on the selected caregiver, service, duration, pets, and add-ons, with applicable fees shown before confirmation.
Do not describe a platform guarantee as ordinary pet-sitter insurance. Rover says its Guarantee reimburses certain eligible costs during bookings made and paid through Rover, subject to exclusions, limits, and required owner contributions. It excludes several categories, including pre-existing or chronic conditions and events outside confirmed service dates. Read the current terms rather than relying on a dollar headline.
With an independent sitter, ask for evidence of business insurance, references, a written service agreement, cancellation terms, and an emergency plan. Pet Sitters International's interview guidance recommends an introductory meeting and asking about insurance designed for pet-care businesses. Platform profile badges and independent-business credentials answer different questions; neither replaces a meet-and-greet and written care plan.
Holiday Pricing: What to Expect
Expect the booking total—not a generic nightly number—to matter. Rover says sitters can set holiday, additional-pet, extended-care, extended-stay, puppy, and pickup/drop-off rates. If any booking date overlaps Rover's defined holiday period, the holiday rate can apply to the entire booking. Wag says caregiver rates vary and its final booking screen shows applicable fees and surcharges.
Independent sitters set their own policies. Ask for the exact holiday dates, cancellation deadline, deposit or prepayment terms, and total for every pet in writing. Availability changes too quickly for this directory to promise that a sitter will fill a specific number of weeks in advance, so confirm availability directly.
What to Confirm Before You Book
Ask for one written quote covering the same dates, pets, visit duration, overnight presence, walks, medications, holiday treatment, added fees, taxes, cancellation terms, and payment schedule. A low base rate is not comparable if the final scope differs.
Before providing home access or transferring care, confirm identity and references; business insurance or the exact platform protection terms; who else can enter your home or handle your pet; other animals and client pets present at a boarding home; emergency contacts and spending authorization; key or access-code handling; the update schedule; and what happens if the sitter becomes unavailable.
Schedule a meet-and-greet appropriate to the service and pet. It may be free or paid—do not assume. Use it to walk through routines, handling limits, equipment, medication instructions, escape risks, and emergency transport. Put the final care plan and authorization in writing.
Sources and Method
This guide was rechecked July 21, 2026. Published national baselines come from Rover's 2026 dog-sitting rate guide and 2026 cat-sitting rate guide. Booking mechanics were checked against Rover's rate and added-charge explanation, Guarantee summary, and Wag's service-pricing page. Hiring questions draw on Pet Sitters International's interview checklist. No unpublished local booking data was represented as a Westchester average.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many drop-in visits does my dog need per day?
There is no safe universal number. Age, species, health, medication, feeding, toileting, anxiety, and the total time alone all matter. Write down your pet's normal routine and ask your veterinarian when medical or age-related needs are involved. A sitter should agree to a specific schedule rather than infer it from a generic article.
Is Rover cheaper than hiring a local independent sitter?
Not predictably. Rover sitters set their own rates, independent sitters set theirs, and each may add different charges or include different care. Compare the final written total for the same dates and scope, along with cancellation terms, protection or insurance, references, and the care plan.
What happens if my sitter cancels last minute?
Read the platform or independent sitter's current cancellation and replacement policy before booking. Ask who contacts you, whether a substitute can enter your home or handle your pet without separate approval, what happens to payment, and who your backup contact will be. Keep a second vetted option for time-sensitive travel.
Do pet sitters charge extra for administering medication?
Policies and capabilities vary. Disclose the exact medication, route, timing, handling needs, and veterinary instructions before booking. Ask the sitter to confirm in writing whether they can perform the task and whether it changes the price. For specialized or high-risk care, ask your veterinarian what qualifications or alternative arrangements are appropriate.
Find Providers Now
Browse listed providers in our directory, compare ratings, read reviews, and contact them directly.
Related Guides
The Pets Near You team researches pet services across Westchester, Fairfield, Putnam, and Rockland counties to help pet owners find trusted local providers.